Legislature(2003 - 2004)
02/24/2004 01:40 PM Senate TRA
Audio | Topic |
---|
* first hearing in first committee of referral
+ teleconferenced
= bill was previously heard/scheduled
+ teleconferenced
= bill was previously heard/scheduled
SB 298-OFF-ROAD VEHICLE USE ON DALTON HIGHWAY CO-CHAIR WAGONER announced SB 298 to be up for consideration. SENATOR RALPH SEEKINS, sponsor, referencing his sponsor statement, said the state's statutes prevail over Bureau of Land Management (BLM) statutes, when they more restrictive. The Dalton Highway was opened to public use during the Hickel administration and now, 10 years later, it is time to allow public use of the lands on either side of it. There is no reason not to it is done safely and with care for the environment. SB 298 asks that the statute be totally repealed. CO-CHAIR WAGONER asked if the five-mile prohibition was for recreation and hunting only. SENATOR SEEKINS replied it was for any purpose whatsoever, but it does not apply to off-road vehicles necessary for oil and gas exploration, development, production or transportation, or to a person who holds a mining claim in the vicinity of the highway who must use land within five miles of right-of way to gain access to it - or if you start on one side of the corridor, you can drive through it to get to the other side, but you can't start in the middle to get to either side. MR. ACE CALLAWAY, Alaska Trappers Association, supported Senator Seekins' description of his dilemma as a trapper. A number of other trappers have been affected; one has a 275-mile long tap line with cabins that he has run for almost 15 years. There is no way he could run that line with on-foot access - and he can't afford the cost of removing the cabins. TAPE 04-5, SIDE B MR. CALLAWAY explained that he is a disabled veteran and his only access to his 250-mile trap line is by snowmobile. One solution is to do away with the statute and another would be for the state to make vehicle access points through the corridor. He favored deleting the statute. DR. BRIAN PEARSON, biologist, Department of Wildlife Management, Fairbanks North Star Borough, opposed SB 298 for several reasons. Removing the five-mile corridor along the Dalton Highway would increase hunting and trapping pressure and harassment of wildlife on the North Slope. This is important for several reasons. First, if you're going to increase the competition between subsistence hunters and sport hunters and this increase in hunting pressure will likely result in a change in regulation that would effect the ability of subsistence hunters to harvest an adequate number of animals to support themselves and their community. Second, and perhaps as important, the Central Arctic herd has served as a good study herd toward the impacts of oil development on caribou on the North Slope. An increase in hunting will certainly change our ability to investigate the impacts of oil development on wildlife. Finally, biologically, caribou likely cannot withstand the increases in combined disturbance from both industry and harvest pressures. Virtually all the caribou herds in the state that can be accessed by roads. Managers have had to impose pretty stringent management efforts to maintain those herds in a viable population. Secondly, removing the corridor is certainly going to cause damage to the tundra from all-terrain vehicles. The North Slope north of the Brooks Range is certainly underlain by permafrost. There are numerous examples that the damage caused by ATVs is long-term.... DR. PEARSON said there is only one state trooper on the North Slope and law enforcement would be a real issue. The oil industry would have security issues that are closely linked with law enforcement. SENATOR THERRIAULT said many of the same arguments were made when the road was opened up and asked if any studies showed its detrimental effects yet. DR. PEARSON replied that hunters had increased in number along the corridor; caribou had been found with arrows in them from an increase in archery hunters there. CO-CHAIR COWDERY reasoned if the law didn't exist, enforcement would not be needed. He didn't think the additional all-terrain vehicle traffic would cause much damage. DR. PEARSON differed saying that different communities are proactive in the efforts they take to protect the tundra. An increase in traffic from the state opening up the Dalton Highway corridor would certainly increase the amount of damage to the tundra. Tundra damage has been documented numerous times. SENATOR THERRIAULT asked if he would support establishing a minimum snow cover. DR. PEARSON replied that would certainly mitigate the effects on the tundra, but that doesn't discount his other concerns about an increase in hunting pressure. MR. LEE OLSON, Fairbanks, said he is also a disabled veteran and he supports SB 298 because it would help give him access to hunting. SENATOR LINCOLN asked him what game he hunts. He replied caribou. MR. DICK BISHOP, Fairbanks, supported SB 298. It's time to recognize that the potential affects on lands and waters can be regulated under other statutes. SENATOR THERRIAULT asked him for examples of other statutes and regulations that could be used to mitigate the impacts of increased access. MR. BISHOP said the Board of Game and the Division of Sport Fisheries (DSF) could use their regulations and the Department of Natural Resources (DNR) has land management authority over state lands. MR. RAYMOND PANEAK, Anaktuvik Pass hunter, opposed SB 298 because the added hunting competition would have detrimental affects on the caribou herds and their wintering grounds. He was also concerned about ATVs destroying the tundra. SENATOR LINCOLN asked him to explain how opening the corridor would affect his village. MR. PANEAK responded that subsistence hunters and trappers would be adversely affected. "We're going to have problems." SENATOR LINCOLN asked Mr. Paneak if he was speaking for all the people of Anaktuvik Pass. MR. PANEAK replied that he is speaking for his village, Nuiqsut and all the villages in his area. They use the same caribou herd. MR. MATT ROBUS, Director, Division of Wildlife Conservation, Alaska Department of Fish and Game (ADF&G), said he wasn't taking a position on this bill at this time, but he wanted to present some wildlife considerations for the committee's information. Foremost of these would be management of the Central Arctic caribou herd. At present that herd can sustain a maximum allowable harvest of about 1,500 animals annually. If the taking of the ORV vehicle restrictions were to stimulate a very large increase in hunting effort, we could be in the position where the Board of Game would have to consider using season and bag limit restrictions or some other mechanism to restrict hunting pressure to be at an allowable level. If that became restrictive of subsistence opportunity, you could see either the state or the federal subsistence process start to distinguish between which hunters could participate in that hunt.... We have some similar considerations for Dall Sheep and musk ox seasons along the Haul Road because those populations cannot sustain large increases in the hunting pressure from where they are at presently. MR. ROBUS said the Board of Game has used other tools and one of those is a regulation that is currently in effect for a Dalton Highway management area that goes from the Yukon River north to Dead Horse. That regulation, which was promulgated under the state's wildlife management statutes, AS 16.05.255, would remain in effect even if this statute were repealed. As presently written, that regulation tightly controls the use of any motorized vehicle with exceptions for hunting and does not restrict it at all for trapping. Use of motorized vehicles to assist trapping is within bounds under our regulation. However, hunting is restricted to bow and arrow within five miles of the highway and motorized vehicles are not allowed to be used unless they are airplanes, boats or a licensed highway vehicle on a publicly maintained road. Those can be adjusted one way or the other by the Board of Game, but those are the type of management restrictions that have been put into place by the board to mediate the amount of hunting that occurs in that part of the state. That's for biological reasons. If that does stay in affect, I want to point out that that would only restrict hunting and would not restrict the use of off-road vehicles (ORVs) for other purposes for anything from mining to berry picking, I suppose. So, we could still have some effects from repealing this statute in terms of harassment of game. He pointed out that the regulatory system along the Dalton Highway is very tangled and urged caution in undoing everything, because it could lead to using regulations to cure impacts that would be more painful to live with than what there is now. SENATOR LINCOLN said she thought more law enforcement would be needed because of the harassment and killing of animals that might already be in scarce supply. She asked how many troopers were in the area now and how many would be needed. MR. ROBUS replied that the Bureau of Wildlife Enforcement is recruiting for a position to be filled in Coldfoot. Typically, one trooper has been in that post. "I think it's safe to say that if you have more hunting activity and more hunting pressure or other forms of interaction with wildlife, you would also have more enforcement need." SENATOR SEEKINS asked if he found a negative impact on moose herds from the use of all terrain vehicles in the Talkeetna area. MR. ROBUS replied that issue is debated and he didn't have any documented effects. Some people think there are fewer places for game to take refuge in Unit 13. His point is that vehicle restriction is a management tool that is used by the board that would have to go to another tool if game herds were negatively impacted. Of all the uses that might occur, he couldn't speculate on how much activity would be related to hunting, but probably a lot. SENATOR SEEKINS pointed out that that area is so remote, that people have to be wealthy enough to fly in to access it. It seems to him that there shouldn't be exclusive access to lands in the state of Alaska. SENATOR LINCOLN said she is very familiar with the road since she uses it a lot in the summer. There hasn't been a place that I have pulled over that I haven't seen oil drums and oil cans and garbage cans and diapers. There is an immense amount of garbage on that highway. During moose hunting season I think I counted almost 400 trailers that were parked by the bridge up there. We have put out fires on both sides of the river from people who were careless.... I would expect if that corridor were opened - and public safety is a real concern - enforcement is a real concern. There just isn't the enforcement up there now to accommodate the traffic that's there.... TAPE 04-6, SIDE A SENATOR LINCOLN said she would like to think that the good citizens of the state of Alaska would leave that area the same way it was when they arrived, but she can attest that that is not the case. SENATOR SEEKINS said he travels the Haul Road, too, and knows that hundreds of trucks travel it every week and he thought their use should be accommodated. Just to say that because someone else in the past may have not been sensitive to how they got rid of oil cans or anything else, in my opinion, is not reason to limit the people of the state of Alaska to have access to millions of acres of lands and to be able to use those lands responsibly. I think we can accommodate both uses.... CO-CHAIR WAGONER said there would be an additional hearing on this bill and closed today's hearing. He adjourned the meeting at 3:25 p.m.
Document Name | Date/Time | Subjects |
---|